Career and Workplace

Why Low-Wage Workers Get Stuck—and What Companies Can Do

Millions of workers are changing jobs without getting ahead—and employers are paying a price in turnover, productivity, and morale. Research by Joseph Fuller explains how companies can help them advance while building a stronger workforce.

A sprawling blue-gray maze viewed from above, with magenta spheres scattered throughout and a translucent magenta path cutting diagonally across the maze.

The American Dream certainly holds a hopeful promise: If you start at the bottom and work hard, you can climb your way up. But that’s not the reality for many people, a recent study finds.

Most workers who start in low-wage jobs struggle to find a clear path to the middle class, instead remaining stuck in low-paying work for years—and in many cases for their entire careers, according to research by Harvard Business School Professor Joseph Fuller.

“It becomes a spiderweb, where you’re caught and really can’t get out of the trap,” Fuller says. “America loves a Horatio Alger story. What we have to remember is, Horatio Alger wrote fiction.”

About 42 million Americans work in low-wage jobs, and many end up stuck because they have limited access to the career information and training they need to move into better-paying work, Fuller says. Plus, a labor market being reshaped by artificial intelligence is creating an even bigger challenge for workers trying to keep pace with shifting skill requirements. Meanwhile, businesses often feel the impact as well, with high turnover leading to higher costs and lower productivity and morale.

It becomes a spiderweb, where you’re caught and really can’t get out of the trap.

Fuller, the MBA Class of 1960 Professor of Management Practice, provides advice to both college officials and business leaders about ways to improve the labor landscape in the April report “Pivots Without Pathways: Career Navigation in a Fragmented Labor Market.” Fuller, co-chair of the Project on Workforce, an interdisciplinary research initiative between HBS, Harvard Kennedy School, and Harvard Graduate School of Education, coauthored the report with a team of collaborators associated with the project: Kerry McKittrick, Amanda Holloway, Rony Rodriguez Ramirez, Candace Megerssa, and Allyson Dennis.

People jump between low-paying jobs

To better understand how people navigate the labor market, the researchers surveyed more than 1,000 low-wage workers—those with an average annual income less than $40,000—and 264 community college students, plus they conducted interviews and led focus groups with workers, students, and career coaches.

“We wanted to get a real sense of the stories people told and match that to the survey data, to find out what people actually do,” Fuller says.

The results revealed a pattern: People often expected to start at the bottom and work their way up, but more often than not found themselves stuck in one low-wage position after the next, with nearly half of career moves being lateral or “reactive.”

Why workers get stuck in a low-wage cycle

Why? As Fuller and his colleagues analyzed the data to more closely determine how people land in the low-wage trap, the team found several factors at play:

Challenges limit people’s opportunities.

Participants said layoffs, shifting caregiving responsibilities, health problems, immigration issues, academic misalignment, and other challenges drove them to regularly change positions without advancing.

People lack marketable skills.

Fuller argues that a deficient education system isn’t giving people the practical skills they need to thrive in a competitive job market. For one thing, many high schools eliminated vocational training decades ago. Plus, often people who start college don’t finish, with only 40% of people in their prime college years graduating—and that’s because for many, higher education isn’t affordable, Fuller says.

“They are leaving high school or starting some post-secondary education and dropping out, either because they need to work to support their families, or they want to be independent,” Fuller says. “They don’t have any particular skills that have value in the labor market, so they take a job they can get—one with a low skills threshold—which by definition doesn’t pay well.”

Workers prioritize immediate stability over advancing.

Low-paying jobs see high turnover as employees constantly pivot to find a position that pays a little more, has a better schedule, or entails a shorter commute. Workers often prioritize finding immediate stability in pay and predictable hours over seeking advancement. “People don’t understand they are starting to build a job history that says ‘I work in a low-wage, low–skills threshold job.’ If they string together a succession of such positions, they will be effectively barred from getting a better job due to lack of relevant experience,” Fuller says.

Jobseekers lack helpful guidance.

Many people looking for work don’t have access to high-quality information to help guide their career choices. For one thing, people often become overwhelmed by misleading job postings, as well as automated hiring algorithms that provide little feedback, and they end up losing trust in online systems to the point that they abandon applications. To find jobs, they often rely on informal networks, such as friends and family members, who may not provide the objective, informed advice they need to advance.

How to get people on the right track

To help get people on a more stable pathway to advancement, Fuller provides the following advice to college officials and business leaders:

Help students map a career path.

Community college career offices can help job seekers by asking about their skills and aspirations, then using that information to identify a profession, choose the right courses, and map out a series of jobs that could lead to steady promotion within a particular field. Fuller also suggests AI could help supplement the process, allowing workers to describe their skills and ambitions in plain language to research possibilities and map out a potential career trajectory.

Connect students and workers with mentors who understand their circumstances.

Mentoring programs can pair jobseekers with people from similar backgrounds who have successfully advanced in their careers. Fuller sees such mentors as a way to strengthen the informal networks workers already rely on while providing successful models of upward mobility.

Invest in training workers instead of assuming they will leave.

Companies should provide both formal and on-the-job training to help people advance to higher positions. Too many suffer from the “destructive delusion” that newly skilled employees will leave their companies. Fuller says many workers aren’t eager to go through the trouble of finding a new job when they’re treated well. “It shocks many people to learn that the majority of low-wage workers think their job is fine, and don’t really want to leave their employer,” he says.

Invest in trying to get people to stay, and the number one way to do that is to find a way for them to be more productive and make more.

Give workers opportunities to do more—and earn more.

Training doesn't necessarily have to mean moving someone into a different job. Companies can give workers opportunities to take on more advanced tasks within their existing positions, making the work more interesting while increasing their productivity and pay. “Invest in trying to get people to stay, and the number one way to do that is to find a way for them to be more productive and make more,” Fuller says.

Make training worthwhile even when workers do leave.

Companies shouldn't assume training is wasted if an employee eventually takes a job elsewhere. Fuller points to Amazon and Walmart as examples of companies with robust programs that teach workers skills they can use to advance into higher-paying jobs. Even when workers move on, he argues, they are likely to stay longer to complete the training and will also recommend the company to friends and family.

Illustration created with image from Adobe Stock.

Have feedback for us?

Latest from HBS faculty experts

Expertly curated insights, precisely tailored to address the challenges you are tackling today.

Strategy and Innovation

Social Responsibility

Data and Technology